2021
- Bella Avila – University of Tampa
- Mollie Estepp – University of Denver
2020
- Paige Haughn – Queens University
- Grace Kennedy – Wittenberg University
- Molly Kershner – College of Wooster
- Riley Kuehn – Dickinson College
- Gillian O’Rourke – Slippery Rock University
- Liz Renken – Colorado Mesa
- Carli Rigel – Otterbein University
- Sydney Stone – Grand Valley State University
- Jackie Wolford – Kent State University
2019
- Toria Banks – Liberty University
- Molly Bursinger – Grand Valley State University
- Sophia Finotti – University of Cincinnati
- Zoe Kellerman – Rollins College
- Gabby Rothermund – Regis University
2018
- Kelley Blevins – Baldwin Wallace University
- Mollie McCormack – University of Delaware
- Hannah McFeeters – Walsh University
- Brenna Smith – Florida Southern College
2017
- Molly Berend – Florida Southern College
- Jennie Finotti – University of Cincinnati
- Jaclyn Gilmore – Ursuline College
- Addie Hamilton – United States Naval Academy
- Emily Kraker – St. Mary’s College
- Maddie Krock – Gannon University
2016
- Meg Morgan – San Diego State University
- Ema Pusecker – Otterbein University
- Rachel Reinhart – Wilmington College
2015
- Dani Bursinger – Florida Southern University
- Stevie Jefferis – Davidson University
- Alex McCafferty – University of Detroit Mercy
- Megan Sengelmann – University of Tampa
- Katie Stegmann – University of Cincinnati
- Kaitlin Troutner – Slippery Rock University
- McKenna Walquist – Otterbein University
2014
- Sam Bolon – Lynchburg College
- Liza Carey – San Diego State University
- Sarah Dawley – Duquesne University
- Courtney Gittins – Rollins College
- Kara Hines – Capital University
- Armonde Moore – University of Cincinnati
